CO129-454 - Acting Governor Claud Severn - 1919 [4-6] — Page 191

CO129 Colonial Office Hong Kong Records 理藩院香港檔案 All

Separate & Joint actions

P. 164,

Justification,

P. 172

P. 18

Fair comment.

P. 184

Fair comment.

p. 186.

p. 187.

Quus.

p. 188.

187

Truth, if pleaded, is a complete

de fence.

But it must justify the whole of

the words in the Statement of C1 sin.

Must be done fairly not actionable

so long as writer states his real

opinion.

De fence will fail unless words are

comment and not the assertion of

Bome alleged matter of fact,

on defendant,

A comment is the expression of the judgment passed upon certain alleged

facts by one who has applied his

mind to them, and who, while 50

commenting assumes that such alie ga-

tions of fact are true.

If the words complained of contain

allegations of fact which are denied

by plaintiff and which the defendant

cannot prove to be true there must

be a verdict for the plaintiff,

I

X

X

X

-15-

It is one thing to comment on or

criticise even with severity the

ac knowledged or proved acts of a

public man and quite another to

assert that he has been guilty of

Comments

Approved members can add comments, bookmarks, and private notes.

No comments yet.

Private Research Note

Private notes are available after approval.